Please log in

Paper / Information search system




Please log in

  • Summary & Details

Model Release Process using Standardized Error Metrics for Validation of X-in-the-Loop Simulation Models

Detailed Information

Author(E)1) Vedantha Narasimha, 2) Manish Nayak, 3) Alexander Bick
Affiliation(E)1) Mercedes-Benz R&D India Pvt Ltd, 2) Mercedes-Benz R&D India Pvt Ltd, 3) Mercedes-Benz AG
Abstract(E)The current automotive market is dynamic, leading to complex functionalities being incorporated into the control software of various components like engine, gearbox, battery, E-motor etc. This results in utilization of virtual environments for software testing to reduce the development time. The virtual platforms under the category X-in-the-Loop (XiL) e.g. Software-in-the-Loop (SiL) and Hardware-in-the-Loop (HiL) use simulated models to achieve a desired test goal. These component models must be rigorously validated to ensure the quality of XiL-Testing. Thus, it is essential to define a model release process that maintains model quality irrespective of the modeling approach used and the user. One of the challenges is to choose an appropriate Error Metric (EM) that sets criteria for model release. This paper proposes a combination of Theil’s Inequality Coefficient (TIC) and Unscaled Mean Bounded Relative Absolute Error (UMBRAE) as the EM. TIC is used to characterize the steady and non-dynamic variables. In contrast, UMBRAE is used to characterize transient dynamic variables. The entire operating range of the component model is validated using this combination of EM. This paper presents the process to validate an engine plant model against test-bench measurements. The quality level of each output signal is categorized as “excellent” if EM is less than 1, “good” if EM is less than 5, or “acceptable” if the EM is less than 10. The mean of EM of all signals represents the overall model quality and maximum of EM represents the worst-case scenario. The inaccurate signals and corresponding functionalities can be promptly identified through the process. These models can be iteratively improved to ensure that the quality demands are met for all the signals.

About search


How to use the search box

You can enter up to 5 search conditions. The number of search boxes can be increased or decreased with the "+" and "-" buttons on the right.
If you enter multiple words separated by spaces in one search box, the data that "contains all" of the entered words will be searched (AND search).
Example) X (space) Y → "X and Y (including)"

How to use "AND" and "OR" pull-down

If "AND" is specified, the "contains both" data of the phrase entered in the previous and next search boxes will be searched. If you specify "OR", the data that "contains" any of the words entered in the search boxes before and after is searched.
Example) X AND Y → "X and Y (including)"  X OR Z → "X or Z (including)"
If AND and OR searches are mixed, OR search has priority.
Example) X AND Y OR Z → X AND (Y OR Z)
If AND search and multiple OR search are mixed, OR search has priority.
Example) W AND X OR Y OR Z → W AND (X OR Y OR Z)

How to use the search filters

Use the "search filters" when you want to narrow down the search results, such as when there are too many search results. If you check each item, the search results will be narrowed down to only the data that includes that item.
The number in "()" after each item is the number of data that includes that item.

Search tips

When searching by author name, enter the first and last name separated by a space, such as "Taro Jidosha".